Tuesday, May 5, 2015

City Council Meeting - May 5, 2015

Work Session

Discussion on fire concerns and fireworks. Last year for the east side of Canyon Road we prohibited aerials and open fires. The city encouraged those who wanted to light fireworks to do so at Mesquite Park as a fire truck would be there and available. We’ve already had a fire this week. Some teens started a bonfire in the foothills and it got out of control so the fire department was dispatched. Chief Freeman would like to prohibit open fires on the east side of Canyon Road, including the foothills. He is talking with the Forest Service on this as well. Feels we should currently have the same restrictions as we did last year with the knowledge that there may be additional restrictions later on based on weather conditions. Chief Freeman indicated that predictions are this summer will be as dry as it was in 2013, which is when Alpine dealt with the Quail Fire.

Discussion on American Fork Canyon Vision Project. This is a group of stakeholders to discuss recreation and transportation issues in American Fork Canyon. They have had one townhall meeting that was well attended. Additional studies are being done and is being funded by the state legislature as well as individuals/businesses in the private sector. Forest Service is very involved as they are concerned about the damage being caused in the canyon. There is approximately 1.5 million visits to the Canyon each year. They will continue to have townhall meetings and other public outreach to get feedback from interested citizens.

Council Meeting

Public Comment
Jerry Dearinger – Encourages the Council to reconsider the situation with Kim Holindrake, former city recorder. Doesn’t claim to be giving legal opinion, but has reviewed case law and her contract and it appears to him that she was railroaded and made part of a situation she didn’t create but has caused her damage, including loss of retirement opportunity. Would like city to reinstate her retirement or give her credit for years worked prior to retirement being put in place. He didn’t always agree with Kim but felt she was honest and knowledgeable.

Paul Sorensen – Ask Mayor & Council on behalf of Kim Holindrake to restore six years of retirement funding. Kim voluntarily resigned in May 2012 but he feels this was forced. Kim’s career was destroyed and compromised. Feels former Mayor Richardson and former city manager Konrad Hildebrandt should be questioned. Brought up Mr. Richardson’s personal legal issues. Feels she was placed under duress to sign separation agreement. Mr. Sorensen read parts of her separation agreement.

Curt Crosby – Mr. Crosby continued reading the letter started by Mr. Sorensen. Continued to read portions of Mrs. Holindrake’s separation agreement. Mr. Crosby says she was threatened with immediate firing so it was signed under duress. Feels this is a travesty forced onto an employee. Feels circumstances were questionable. Mr. Dearinger’s legal opinion is that the separation agreement is unenforceable. Brought up Mr. Richardson’s personal legal issues. Asks for restoration of six years of retirement and wants something in writing.

Sam Bushman – Mr. Bushman is a talk show host but says he doesn’t usually deal with city issues. Has seen Cedar Hills in the news on multiple occasions. News has not been favorable. Filed a GRAMA request and eventually had mediation meeting with the State Records Ombudsman and the city. He feels there was a debate amongst the mayor and city attorney and realized things aren’t as transparent as he’d like them to be. Wanted city business emails and compared it to Hillary Clinton email scandal. CM Crawley was the only council member willing to sign Mr. Bushman’s affidavit. Wants to discuss solutions to transparency in Cedar Hills.
**For further information on this issue, please see the GRAMA portion of the 2014 State of the City Newsletter or see my post titled GRAMA on my blog.

Ken Cromar – Feels Kim Holindrake was forced to sign a contract. Claims an illegal meeting took place before the Council meeting in May 2012. (Reality is that the Council met to celebrate my birthday with cake before the meeting). Asks why a mayor and city attorney would ask an employee to sign the separation agreement Kim signed. Says it says more about the former mayor and attorney. Would like mayor and Council to add to her retirement for the years she worked for the city prior to the retirement plan being implemented.

Michael Johnson – Received an email from Jeff Maag about gating off the road on Heiselt’s Hollow. Mr. Johnson has expressed concern about the speed of the cars coming down the hill. Felt the city should install a speed bump to solve this and water issues. Concrete barriers were installed but this was detrimental to fire trucks that needed access to the hillside when we had a fire in 2013. Feels there is no enforcement to the problems occurring in that area. He is against gating off that area. Would like the employees to talk to the residents who live in that area on solutions.

Consent Agenda
Minutes from the April 14, 2015 and April 21, 2015 City Council meetings were approved.

City Reports
CM Rees – A few members of the Planning Commission, City Council, and staff met with Blu Line to discuss the concerns the Planning Commission had with the renderings submitted at the last meeting. Everyone present gave feedback to Blu Line regarding the design and look of the building. The Planning Commission has agreed to hold a special meeting on May 12th to review updated plans. The Planning Commission changed their regularly scheduled meetings and these will now take place on the fourth Tuesday of every month.

The Daily Herald has been in contact with us on a few stories, one of those being water restrictions.

Family Festival committee is working hard. The magazine is with the printers and should go out next week. Banners are now up at the fire station and roundabout. More will go up as they receive approval. Tickets are now on sale and for the first time, can be purchased online. Sponsorship money has exceeded the targeted amount and plans for all events are scheduled.

The Arts Committee will meet again in May but things are going well. Auditions for the play HONK are complete and practices are being held. The summer concert series is being planned and the concert for Family Festival is booked, which consists of Peter Condor, Sabrina Haskett, and the Bayloaf 4. The Childrens Art Show is planned as part of the Family Festival.

Mayor Gygi – Meets with MAG this Thursday and will report back.

David Bunker – Community Center is getting very busy and scheduling more complex but they work through it. HONK practice is occurring in the basement, as well as karate and other recreation. Golf course is doing well. Tball and lacrosse registration is now open. Soccer programs are currently occurring.
CM Zappala – Worked with Chandler to put together a survey regarding the General Plan and will be sent to residents. Received a grant to continue developing a city tracker app.

CM Geddes – For UV Dispatch, 8 RFP’s were received for construction of new dispatch facility. Parks & Trails had a city day of service last week. One project was beautifying the entrance to Cedar Hills at the south on Canyon Road. Second project was beautifying the roundabout on Cedar Hills Drive. Third project was cleaning up trash among trail system. Several residents participated with all of these projects, guessing about 50. Advertising in wards may help get additional help in the future.

Review/Action on FY 2015 Budget Amendments
10-69-910       Additional transfer up to $250,000 (minimum of $100,000) to the Capital Projects fund for approved capital projects: Bayhill Park, and the golf maintenance shed.  Also, to maintain the unrestricted fund balance in the General fund below 25% of revenues, as required by law.
·         Staff is working on designs for golf maintenance shed and surveying land. This is a placeholder for next fiscal year. CM Crawley feels we should do an analysis on other options for the golf course prior to building this shed. CM Geddes indicated this analysis shouldn’t preclude moving forward on a shed that will be safe for staff. CM Zappala asked CM Crawley when he anticipates working on this analysis. CM Crawley stated he has started but will work on this more and needs some help in various areas. Doesn’t know how long it will take but wants to start the conversation. CM Augustus felt we’ve done this already with the Golf Course Financial Advisory Committee, which came back with a unanimous recommendation that we should continue with the golf course as there was no other viable option. CM Crawley feels that other options were not discussed in detail with the Golf Course Finance Committee. He feels other options haven’t been researched enough. CM Geddes welcomes the discussion but hates to bring up angst for a small portion of the population. CM Crawley feels it isn’t a small portion of the population that is concerned with golf course losses. He feels that we need to do a thorough analysis of other options. My thoughts are that this maintenance shed was discussed over a year ago and this analysis has been discussed for over a year. If it’s going to be done, it needs to be done within the next few months. We can’t continue to push this off for another year.
·         On Bayhill Park, the FY 2015 budget will be used to redesign the park according to recommendations made by the Parks & Trails Committee to increase size of play equipment, landscaping, and moving trail to aqueduct easement.

10-35-100            Increase by $5,000 Family Festival Income relating to donations. 

10-65-600            Increase Family Festival expenditures by $5,000 related to the dinner.

10-69-911            Transfer to Motor Pool Fund, reallocated to various motor pool charge accounts 10-40-275, 10-60-275, 10-61-275, and 10-65-275. These are just reclassifications.

20-80-911            Transfer to Motor Pool Fund, updated to motor pool charge account 20-80-275.

40-30-801            Additional transfer in from the General fund up to $250,000 for approved capital projects and to keep unrestricted fund balance in General fund less than 25% of revenues, as required by law.

40-30-500            Mass Transit Sales Tax Revenues levied by the city, but collected and 40-78-100 disbursed by the State of Utah for mass transit projects/operations, which amounted to less than $10 in the previous fiscal year. This is no longer collected by the city as the County instituted a county mass transit sales tax.

51-75-911            Transfer to Motor Pool Fund updated to 51-73-275 Motor Pool Charges (just a reclassification)

51-38-380            Sewer impact fees collected for Timpanogos Special Service District (TSSD), and 51-74-471 sewer impact fees distributed to TSSD.

This was approved.

Review/Action to Adopt Tentative Fiscal Year 2016 Budget
The City is also required to approve a tentative budget for 2015-2016 by the first Council Meeting in May based on Utah Code 10-6-135. The final budget will not be approved until June, so there is still time to review any questions or concerns. A few highlights:
·         Charl showed an analysis comparing 2006 to 2016. In 2016 the majority of our revenue (29%) came from licensing and permits. In 2016, the majority of our revenue comes from sales tax (31%). Property tax has stayed at about 20%.
·         Increase in Class C road funds as State Legislature passed an increase in gas tax. This starts January 2016 so the budgeted amount is for half of a year with an increase of $22,000.
·         Wage increases are an average of 3%. Health insurance benefits increasing 5.46% and dental insurance premium increasing 3.5%.
·         Golf operating revenues up $24,868 from prior year though end of March.
·         Legal expenses projected to increase by $20,000 from the FY 2015 budgeted amount.
·         Auditing services projected to decrease by $9000.
·         Election expenses increases to $15,000 as next year is an election year.
·         Public safety expenses increases as follows: Fire/EMS $1,735, Police $18,049, Dispatch $32,000.
·         Placeholder of $8000 for contributing to a mental health provider at Lone Peak High School (this will require many future discussion with the district and other cities and is just a placeholder).
·         Motor Pool charges of $50,907 are a change in how budgeted items are shown. In the past it was a transfer to the golf fund. This is for approved purchases of maintenance equipment.
·         Parks expenditures will now show a line for utilities. Projected amount is $12,500.
·         Increase in salaries and benefits for Community Services. We added a part-time custodian as it was cheaper than contracting out.
·         Recreation class expense decreasing by $15,000 as Tree Fitness isn’t currently offering classes at the facility.
·         Golf Course utilities increase of $31,000 to show water usage.
·         Water fees increasing $34,281 for residential and $37,750 for city departments, such as golf course and city parks. Increase is based on Bowen & Collins study done in 2012. Additionally, as part of this study and recommendation, sewer fees are increasing $54,065 and storm drain fees are increasing $16,928. These increases are to cover estimated operations, capital projects, and debt service for the water, sewer, storm drain, and PI systems.
·         TSSD is increasing $49,000 and this is a pass through cost.

CM Zappala indicated he’d like to see the golf subsidy go down each year. It did increase this upcoming year to account for new policy on accounting for utilities and for golf maintenance equipment approved for purchase.

This was approved.

Review/Action on Water Restrictions
In an effort to maintain the ability to consistently provide an adequate supply of secondary water during peak usage periods and during unexpected maintenance times, staff has made recommendations for long term system changes including a tiered billing schedule. However, at this time a City prescribed watering schedule is under consideration. Staff acknowledges that past prescribed water scheduling has resulted in spiked water usage that exceeded the system’s ability to provide the required supply. This resulted in low water pressures to many areas of the City. Unlike many jurisdictions with large water storage facilities that need extended time to refill, Cedar Hills has a few small reservoirs that during high usage can be rapidly drained. We have found that consistent nightly usage, spread out daily, allows us to maximize delivery of available water and provide the most consistent water pressure.

Staff recommends that if water schedules are used, the City should be divided into six watering zones; three zones on the upper system and three zones on the lower system. Each watering zone would be scheduled to water twice weekly, by address (odd/even), this will help maintain supply and pressure during usage. Sunday would be open for spot watering only (hose) city wide. Staff recommends that this schedule be followed from May 1st through September 30th and particularly through the critical months of June, July and August. To help avoid the past experience of water usage increase staff recommends that enforcement of the water schedule be consistent and aggressive. To provide enforcement it is anticipated that two part time employees will be needed; at a cost of approximately $22,736. This cost would be covered by the water fund. As this cost would likely be needed on an annual basis it is recommended that it be added to the Bowen Collins study. Fees collected for violations to the policy could provide revenue to partially offset costs. We also anticipate increased depreciation to City vehicles used during the enforcement period. Additional legal costs could be incurred during the enforcement process as well as the need for additional current staff time.

Water Conservation Committee and staff didn’t recommend restrictions as history has shown this has increased water usage. The recommendation from the committee was to implement a citizen education program. This was done last year and will continue this year. There has also been an increase in media coverage. Feels education program could be just as effective as water restrictions.

David stated that our water levels in our wells have dropped and that will get worse with population growth and as more cities rely on culinary water to supplement their PI needs.

Water restrictions will be put in place. We will go to an odd/even watering schedule with enforcement of first violation – warning, second violation - $50 fine, third violation - $200 fine. This was approved unanimously.

No comments: